Top Ten All-Time NFL Rookies
Written by Nolan Thomas, Monday May 04 2009
With the 2009 draft just over a week old, I put together what I believe are the top ten rookie performances of all time. I am sure there is a lot of debate between people on who these should be and in what ranking, however, here are my choices. Let the debates begin!
10. Ben Roethlisberger, QB Pittsburgh Steelers 2004
As a rookie, Roethlisberger went 13–0 during the regular season and 1-1 in the playoffs as the starting quarterback for the Steelers. He helped lead the Steelers to become the first American Football Conference (AFC) team to have 15 wins in a single season. Big Ben came into the season as the number two quarterback and replaced Tommy Maddox as the starter in game four of the season. He surpassed former Steeler quarterback Mike Kruczek’s 6-0 record for the best start by a rookie and exceeded the NFL mark for total wins as a rookie quarterback. After his stellar rookie season, the Associated Press unanimously selected Roethlisberger as the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year. He was the first quarterback in 34 years to be honored as the rookie of the year.
9.
Portis was a second round draft pick for the Broncos in 2002 and his performance was a surprise for both the Broncos and the NFL in his Rookie Season. Not that they did not expect him to be second round pick good, but after his first two games he had gained only 46 total yards and no one from that point was expecting much from Portis his rookie season. However, in week five he was named the starter, and from that point on, Portis opened up everybody’s eyes in the NFL, including the Broncos. He gained 1508 yards on the ground, an average of 5.5 yards per attempt, along with 364 yards receiving with 17 TDs. Fantastic numbers considering he did not start until week five of the season.
8. Curtis Martin, RB
The New England Patriots in the third round of the 1995 NFL Draft chose Martin. He was extremely impressive in his Rookie season as he rushed for a solid 1,487 yards and scored 14 touchdowns on the ground. Martin also had 30 catches for 261 yards and one touchdown. He was elected to the Pro-Bowl and the Associated Press selected Martin as the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year as well.
7. Dick "Night Train" Lane, CB L.A. Rams, 1952
Dick “Night Train” Lane was one of the best players to ever play the Cornerback position. In his rookie season, he quickly showed his talents to the football world as he racked up 14 interceptions with 2 touchdowns that year. His 298 interception return yards that year are ranked fifth all-time in the NFL. His 14 interceptions still stands in the NFL Record books not only for a rookie but also for all players. Lane is fourth on the all time NFL interception list with 68.
6. Randy Moss, WR Minnesota Vikings 1998
There are twenty teams in the NFL that are still shaking their heads and wondering to themselves why they did not draft Moss when they had the chance. He was drafted 21st in the 1998 draft. Moss was projected to be a high first round pick, however, teams were concerned with Moss' well-documented legal problems. Prior to the draft Moss was quoted as saying, “Teams that pass on him will regret it once they see what kind of a player I am and what kind of guy I really am.” To this day those twenty teams still regret it. Moss racked up 69 receptions for 1313 yards receiving with 17 touchdowns, which is a rookie record. Moss was named a Pro Bowl starter and the Associated Press NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year.
5. Earl Campbell, RB
4.
The NFL’s New York Giants drafted
3. Adrian Peterson, RB
Peterson was selected by the Minnesota Vikings with the seventh overall pick in the first round of the 2007 NFL Draft. He rushed for over 1300 yards with 13 Rushing TDs in while only playing in nine games his rookie season. Peterson established Viking team records for a rookie including the most 100-yard games rushing and the longest touchdown run from scrimmage. He also set an NFL single game rushing yard record when he rushed for 296 yards on thirty carries and three touchdowns against the San Diego Chargers. He was named the starting running back for the NFC Pro Bowl team and he was named The Associated Press NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year.
2. Eric Dickerson, RB
Dickerson was the number 2 pick in the 1983 draft, selected behind John Elway. He had the greatest rookie season in the history of the NFL. His 2,212 yards from scrimmage during his 1st-year is ranked 18th all-time. Dickerson holds the NFL All-Time Rookie rushing record with 1808 yards on 390 carries with 18 touchdowns for the season. He was also very versatile out of the backfield as he caught 51 passes for 404 yards with 2 touchdowns. His fabulous rookie season earned him All-Pro, the Pro Bowl, the Player of the Year and Associated Press NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year.
1. Gale Sayers, RB/KR
In his rookie year, Sayers scored an NFL record 22 touchdowns. He had 14 rushing touchdowns along with six receiving touchdowns, one punt return and one kickoff return for touchdowns. He gained 1,374 yards from scrimmage and had a record 2,272 all-purpose yards for a rookie. Sayers tied an NFL record for touchdowns in a single game, with six of them in a 61-20 victory over the
Photo Credit: Rich Gabrielson / Icon SMI
Tags:



Leave a comment
Not So Fast! To publish your comment, you have to login
Not Registered? Register now as it only take 20 seconds!
Click here to browse
5 comments
Please sign in to rate!
Where the HELL is Mike Mamula? The Eagles traded up to draft him (passing on Warren Sapp) and created a whole new statistic to justify the pick. The sad part is that the NFL eventually adopted the "Hurry" and it remains a shining example of mediocrity to this day. That's gotta be worth at least an honorable mention on this list doesn't it?
Please sign in to rate!
two words: Steve Emtman
Please sign in to rate!
I also agree that Moss be moved up to ahead of Peterson, I think where you're selected should have something to do with it. Given that Moss went 21st and Peterson went 7th...You also have to take into account the fact that the Vikings went 15-1 in Moss's rookie season, vs 8-8 in Peterson's.
Please sign in to rate!
I think Roethlisberger should be moved up that list and Martin down. Maybe switch spots. What Roethlisberger did was very impressive, and it takes a lot to command a team like he did as an unproven rookie. I'm a Pats fan and I think what he did was more impressive than Martin's season.
Please sign in to rate!
I wasn't around to see a lot of those guys, but Randy Moss was the greatest rookie I've ever seen. The stats were off the charts and he instantly made that the most explosive offense the NFL has ever seen. Even as a Texas grad I'm a big fan of Peterson, but in my opinion Moss was the best Rookie of my football watching life.